In Math and Science we are making connections to Proverbs. In Science, we are Evaluating Scientific Explanation. In Math, we are analyzing graphs to identify accurate and misleading information. We connected the concepts in these studies to Proverbs 14:15:
“Only simpletons believe everything they are told! The prudent carefully consider their steps.”
I initially had difficulty responding to this article. I read posts by classmates with an open mind hoping to gain some incite. When I read that Prensky is a C.E.O. of a gaming company that was all I needed to put his comments in perspective. Then I found the article,Digital Nativism, Digital Delusions, and Digital Deprivation
posted in Moodle and selected a couple of very informative pieces of critical information from this article by James Mekenzie. He analyzes Prensky's article and highlights the claims that are based on unsubstantiated research or plainly misquoted. There is much more that is definitely worth the time to read. Here are just a couple of Mekenzie's comments.
Insult after Insult
"Digital Immigrants think learning can’t (or shouldn’t) be fun. Why should they – they didn’t spend their formative years learning with Sesame Street."
Where does Prensky come up with this kind of nonsense? Progressive educators have been arguing for learning that is engaging even before the advent of the television. John Dewey, Hilda Taba and many others have argued for learning that appeals to the senses and sparks the curiosity of the young.
Prensky seems to know little about schooling over the decades, and such ignorance is bliss, as it allows him to make preposterous, sweeping, insulting comments about those who have been working over the years.
Prensky took extreme liberties with the work of Dr. Perry, not even bothering to cite his work or spell his name correctly.
If anything, Perry is arguing against the digital world that Prensky welcomes and celebrates:.."
I polled my son, who is a gamer and understands that whole world, and asked him what he thought. He said while there are many good educational games out there, he strongly felt that they don't have a place in the classroom. This is an opinion from a student that teachers would describe as, "difficult to engage." I know this since I have intimate knowledge of his educational experience.
I am not opposed to any TOOL that will truly engage students in learning, but there is no substitute for a teacher who loves the students and uses whatever means possible to create lifetime learners. I will not however, be taken in by a merchant of gaming. When researched based information is available, then I will be glad to integrate it to facilitate higher order learning. There has been entirely too much experimentation in the classroom without substantial research to back up the effectiveness of theoretical curricula.
I will not accept labels and sweeping stereotypes based on age or culture. I end my comments with this thought. It was those who were not born into the technology age that dreamed it and developed it. Never put limitations on anyone.
