In Math and Science we are making connections to Proverbs. In Science, we are Evaluating Scientific Explanation. In Math, we are analyzing graphs to identify accurate and misleading information. We connected the concepts in these studies to Proverbs 14:15:
“Only simpletons believe everything they are told! The prudent carefully consider their steps.”
I initially had difficulty responding to this article. I read posts by classmates with an open mind hoping to gain some incite. When I read that Prensky is a C.E.O. of a gaming company that was all I needed to put his comments in perspective. Then I found the article,Digital Nativism, Digital Delusions, and Digital Deprivation
posted in Moodle and selected a couple of very informative pieces of critical information from this article by James Mekenzie. He analyzes Prensky's article and highlights the claims that are based on unsubstantiated research or plainly misquoted. There is much more that is definitely worth the time to read. Here are just a couple of Mekenzie's comments.
Insult after Insult
"Digital Immigrants think learning can’t (or shouldn’t) be fun. Why should they – they didn’t spend their formative years learning with Sesame Street."
Where does Prensky come up with this kind of nonsense? Progressive educators have been arguing for learning that is engaging even before the advent of the television. John Dewey, Hilda Taba and many others have argued for learning that appeals to the senses and sparks the curiosity of the young.
Prensky seems to know little about schooling over the decades, and such ignorance is bliss, as it allows him to make preposterous, sweeping, insulting comments about those who have been working over the years.
Prensky took extreme liberties with the work of Dr. Perry, not even bothering to cite his work or spell his name correctly.
If anything, Perry is arguing against the digital world that Prensky welcomes and celebrates:.."
I polled my son, who is a gamer and understands that whole world, and asked him what he thought. He said while there are many good educational games out there, he strongly felt that they don't have a place in the classroom. This is an opinion from a student that teachers would describe as, "difficult to engage." I know this since I have intimate knowledge of his educational experience.
I am not opposed to any TOOL that will truly engage students in learning, but there is no substitute for a teacher who loves the students and uses whatever means possible to create lifetime learners. I will not however, be taken in by a merchant of gaming. When researched based information is available, then I will be glad to integrate it to facilitate higher order learning. There has been entirely too much experimentation in the classroom without substantial research to back up the effectiveness of theoretical curricula.
I will not accept labels and sweeping stereotypes based on age or culture. I end my comments with this thought. It was those who were not born into the technology age that dreamed it and developed it. Never put limitations on anyone.
Though I too have concerns about Prensky's approach, I think Mckenzie goes a little far in the other extreme. Though he critique's Prensky's approach, his approach isn't very scientific either. I think the best approach is to evaluate how each individual case fits in to the teaching spectrum. Implementing these tools into the classroom isn't a requirement, but I think that if a teacher wants to try something new and it works, then they should be free to do it (while accounting for the concerns that I and others have). My greater concern is that in the new world, students need to be able to learn how to adjust to change, particularly in the area of technology. How this learning comes isn't as important, but that needs to happen much more than learning content through technology.
ReplyDeleteWow. I am glad I read your post. It gave me a different perspective. I do believe that Prensky ideas have much to offer, but now I also see the flaws. I agree with you that everything goes back to the content and the teacher. It's like a poet and his pencil. Are we supposed to give the pencil any credit for the literature? No,it is only a tool needed to create the art. It all goes back to where the foundation is coming from and these games would never be able to replace a good teacher. If this were a good substitute than we would be using robots as teachers...but then again... watch this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bE4DnQ5GlTc
ReplyDeletePatsy, I laughed at your closing remark. I told my husband about the article and he was VERY insulted being called an Immigrant - he responded that he has been using technology longer than any native, starting way back when with the Commodore and shoe size cell phones. Also liked your reference to Mr. Prensky's role in a company that produces "tools" he is defending. I also noticed this and it helped me keep the article in perspective.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your comment about his claims being unsubstantiated. That was a big frustration for me in his writing. He didn't support his claims well. When he said, ask the children how to do this or that, because they will just know... where does he get that from? I felt like he was claiming to be an expert without proving his authority to speak on the subject, and without backing up his arguments well.
ReplyDeleteI would disagree about the role of games in the classroom. We had digital games in college that helped me learn geology better. It was helpful, because it provided another, effective, way to learn. I don't think they will be effective for all students everywhere, but I do think that students have different learning styles. I still play educational games and learn a lot from them. Part of it comes from the fact that I am a kinesthetic learner, and this helps me learn by doing, and by doing something fun.
You made a lot of good points in your blog. Most I agree with, especially your argument against Prensky saying digital immigrants don't think you should have fun when you are learning. My mom teaches the "Children's Church" kids and she knows how to teach and have fun with the education at the same time. The kids love learning about different Bible passages, stories, characters, Jesus, God, etc. They leave having had fun while learning a lot.
Patsy, I love your opposing arguments and I agree with you as I am also skeptical in how technology should be integrated. However, I can see how some sort of game like tools could keep students engaged. While I think it is important to be careful of what games to implement I think of a teacher is able to make a connection between a game they used and the core of a lesson it could be very beneficial. That being said I also would love to see more research in this area. I am glad you did further research, knowing that Prensky is a CEO of a gaming company adds a entirely new twist to his persuading article. Thanks for the information and inspiring additional research.
ReplyDelete